By John Stapleton
Alex’s barrage began with a story titled “Covid-19: Pundits Queue to Criticise the Prime Minister” and subtitled “Australia’s Collapsing Democracy: A Deficit of Trust”.
OK, warming up.
“Experts have long warned that with the extremely poor quality of government which has characterised the last decade in Australia, the country was rapidly becoming ungovernable.
“Now the future has arrived.
“Normally in times of war or crisis the media rally behind the flag. Not this time around.
“Lie to the people year after year and funnily enough, they stop believing you. The plundering and squandering of the nation’s resources by its plutocrats has ensured there is little or no resilience in the broader population. Within days of the announcement of a nationwide shutdown dole queues snake around the corner in frightening scenes reminiscent of The Great Depression. The pundits are more than happy to put the boot in.”
Followed a sampling of Australian commentary.
From Independent Australia:
“The COVID-19 pandemic could have been an opportunity for Prime Minister Scott Morrison to show leadership but “ScoMo” is only a “notional” national leader.
“The COVID-19 pandemic could have been an opportunity for Morrison to prove his critics wrong. It could have been an opportunity to exercise leadership.
“When your heart’s not in it, it’s hard to get anything right. And Prime Minister Scott Morrison just isn’t invested in the business of governing.”
From Women’s Agenda:
“A new Roy Morgan poll has found New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern has the highest ‘net trust score’ of political leaders, while Australian PM Scott Morrison has a significant ‘net distrust score’.
“At this time, trust in leadership has never been more important.
“Trust at this point can be a matter of life and death: it can determine how people will respond to urgent health messages, whether people will heed the call to stay home and away from crowds.”
From the leading policy journal Pearls and Irritations:
“As so often with Morrison, there is no overall strategy – simply a series of reactive measures which, he hopes, will do the job unless a next one is needed. and then another one, and another one…
“Scott Morrison insists that his message is clear – the government is fully on top of the coronavirus crisis, there is no reason for doubt or uncertainty.
“Viewed individually, ScoMo’s present barrage of edicts are indeed firm and unequivocal. But the problem is that, taken together, they are not only confusing but often self-contradictory.”
From The Sydney Morning Herald:
“A large number of citizens do not trust the government’s response to the pandemic: not just the Morrison government in Canberra, but the state governments, the chief medical officers and the vast health bureaucracies underneath.
“The issue of trust is really important. In this crisis, people have lost trust not only in the authorities but in their fellow citizens.”
From The Saturday Paper:
“Let’s cut to the chase.
They were warned 12 weeks ago by the World Health Organization and others what was coming. They did not accumulate test kits. They did not accumulate the necessary emergency equipment. They did not undertake a public education campaign. They gave no money to science, no money to research, no money to the International Vaccine Institute, no money to WHO. They diligently did not do anything useful.
“Australia’s slow reaction is all the more unforgivable because we were granted, largely due to good luck and geographic isolation, the luxury of time to watch and learn.”
From The New Daily:
“Few could quibble with Mr Morrison’s depiction of this “once-in a-100-year event” as an economic crisis “the likes of which we have not seen since the Great Depression”.
There was sympathy for the Prime Minister’s predicament. One Liberal said he was “caught in a coronavirus swamp with alligators up to his neck”.
“The current Prime Minister has rushed to tell us there was a plan, that we were ahead of the crisis, that we had the best experts, that we just had to remain Australians, that no country could do better.
“It’s that confidence and trust thing. Again.
“Such statements further undermine trust when the government is making it up as it goes along.”
From The Guardian:
“As a coordinated state-directed activity is desperately needed, the fractured relationship between the government and its people becomes obvious.
“We can take issue with the decisions of individual leaders and the urgency of their public health directives, but all are stymied by the decline of trust in their authority, the collapse of the media as a single point of truth and the hollowing out of public services.
“Just 19% of respondents say they have a strong level of trust in information from the government, a consequence of both the low regard in which partisan politicians are held and, I fear, the mixed messages that have been coming from our leaders over recent weeks.
“Australia is crying out for clearer messaging on coronavirus.”
From Australia’s leading public health policy site Croakey:
“Just like the Australian population, our health system has little experience in dealing with a crisis of this scale.
“The realities of responding effectively to the virus have demonstrated the vulnerability of a fragmented, poorly coordinated and inequitable health system.
“The ‘fearful preparation’ response can be seen on every empty supermarket shelf. It has, unfortunately, also been a feature of news reporting.
“Repeated stories of over-purchasing of consumer goods seem likely to be modelling over-purchasing, feeding social contagion and increasing a sense of scarcity. Fearful preparation has escalated into a Tragedy of the Commons, where an essential resource that could readily support everyone’s needs is overused, and so collapses.
Prime Minister Scott Morrison’s coronavirus plans are ‘so far behind … it’s not funny’ and should have been introduced a week ago, a leading disease expert said. ‘The advice on gatherings is way out of date … We’re on the trajectory for the Italian outcome. We have been trying to say it for weeks.
‘We should know how many test kits there are in Australia. They’re kept secret by a secretive government.’
This is an extract from the upcoming book Unfolding Catastrophe by John Stapleton.
A collection of his journalism is being constructed here.
Photography by the author.
